Rewriting History

So, at lunch--thanks to my 22-year-old friend, L--we got into the discussion of what our parents let us take with us when we moved out of their home. L's mother has informed her under no uncertain terms that she is not allowed to take her bedroom suite with her when she moves out next year. L is all in a huff about it because she assumed that she'd take it with her. She was asking her three older friends--me, A. and E.--(I'm not old enough to be an "older friend" dangit!) about our experiences at break this morning.

I told her that when I decided to move out that Mama told me to take all my crap with me because she wanted my room. (She had grand designs of making it into her own den of sorts. She bought a futon and everything.) I mean, seriously, when I moved out at the ripe old age of 22 we packed up every piece of furniture in my room, except for the one piece that was Mama's, and moved it into the lake house. There was no discussion of leaving anything. Nine years later she's still nagging me to come get all the Barbie junk I left in my old closet. To sum up--she kicked all my stuff to the curb when I moved out.

E and A both said they left all their furniture at their parent's house and it's still there to this day.

When L came into the lounge while Mama and I were getting our lunches together, she asked Mama for her opinion on the subject. Mama started off with this sweet little explanation of how she knew I needed my stuff so she encouraged me to take it. So I called her on it. I hadn't needed that old daybed and would have been fine leaving the bookcase of Barbies at her house. I explained again that she'd kicked all my junk out with me when I moved out.

Mama was all, "Stop, you make me sound horrible. I didn't make you take it. I encouraged you to."

So THAT'S why she'd already purchased the futon and drawn up plans for how she wanted to decorate her new "den." I had to beg her to let me keep my old Dalmatians poster on my door!

And I wasn't even trying to make her sound bad. I was trying to make her sound good to L who actually WANTS her mother to let her take her bedroom suit with her. L actually wanted to trade moms. lol But Mama scolded me for making her sound bad.

But she does that a lot, rewriting history to make herself sound better. She does it so often that I've begun to wonder if maybe I'm the one remembering things wrong. I mean, I am notorious for having a bad memory, right? Even if my bad memory does apply more to short term things.

It's not just events in my life, though, that she rewrites. Sometimes she rewrites stories and memories that she's told me for YEARS. Stories about Daddy or her parents. Suddenly if she's retelling the story to friends the story changes to either make her or Daddy sound better or to make someone else look bad. Or she embellishes on old family stories, adding details that I've never heard before and if you asked Daddy about he'd say he didn't recall that part either.

Sis1 is bad about rewriting history, too. Sis2 and I swear she makes stuff up because she's constantly remembering events that Sis2 and I neither one can recall. Or she'll remember an event that she'd only ever heard about but tells it as if she actually lived it.

Me, there are things I wish I could remember but for the life of me can't. Like the time when I was about two or three and I apparently bloodied Sis1's nose when she wouldn't quit pestering me. That's Daddy's favorite story about me and he tells it often. Sometimes Mama tries to add or change details to it but Daddy remembers it as though it were yesterday. Supposedly, Sis1 had been purposefully annoying me and I kept telling her to stop. Several times, Daddy says, I warned her to stop. And I think he said I even told her if she didn't leave me alone I was going to hit her. And according to Daddy the next thing he heard was Sis1 crying and yelling that I'd hit her. Made her nose bleed. Or maybe it was her lip. SEE!? I wish I could remember this event! LOL

Of course, there's also events I wish I could forget. Things I've worked long and hard to erase from my mind. And maybe if I had Mama's gift of rewriting history to suit me, I wouldn't be as screwed up as I am.

But anyway, does anyone else know someone who does this? Or do you do it yourself? Or, are you like me and the events big enough to talk about years later are imprinted clearly on your mind as though they happened yesterday?

Comments

JenFS said…
I've gotten a little worse about remembering every detail. I used to remember everything, small details and all. But now, I'm kinda hazy, especially about subjects when I was younger.

I think the older people get, the more they want the second generation to remember well of them. I think that's why you hear stories that make them sound so glowing. But what do I know? :)
Aunt B said…
I'll bet I'm guilty of this. Jen's right about wanting the younger generation to remember well of us. My memory's certainly not what it used to be. It would be interesting to hear what my daughter would say about this (she's 35). She has never accused me of embellishing my stories...but maybe I've changed some stories a bit to reflect what might have happened instead of what really did if it made it a little more interesting. Isn't that what ALL writers do?LOL You've really given me something to think about, Jana.
Heather said…
Despite the writing gene, I'm not the one in the family known to rewrite history (that would be baby sis). Most people often wonder how I remember some of the things I do. Naturally they're usually the same ones who poke fun one day, then come picking my brain for answers the next. I think the fact that I write things down (journal) helps fix them in my mind.

As for the furniture issue...whatever bedroom furniture we had was ours to take with us when we moved, or leave behind for someone else to use. Most people I know had/have various pieces of furniture (or other items) that was donated to them when they moved out, especially for that first dorm or apartment when they had nothing.
Jana said…
I just caught myself doing it! lol

I told a story at break about Emmy and embellished it a bit to garner a laugh and after I realized what I'd done, I couldn't help but laugh at myself for doing the same sort of thing I had accused my mother of doing.

Just proof, I guess, that we all do it at some point, in some way for some reason. *shrugs*

Popular posts from this blog

I'm Lost

Ten Things That Make Me Happy Today

Me and the boob tube